Momoiro Clover Z vs AKB48: How David beat Goliath

Gekikara-majisuka-gakuen-34648454-1280-720

I see a lot of people going on about how AKB/AKS has the best marketing in the idol industry and that this somehow makes them the best idol group around that can do no wrong, they’re pure and innocent, etc, etc. Well, I say that you are all full of BS.
 

Japan has one of the fastest evolving and rotating industries when it comes to idols. You make a mistake and you will disappear in a heartbeat or simply become irrelevant. So lets break down just what makes each idol group different, from the girls to management. First we need some categories to split things into.

1. Management

  • -Promotion
    -Marketing
  • 2. Music

    3. Members

  • -Personality
    -Character
    -Talent/Skill
  • So those are the things we’ll be looking at. We’ll be focusing mainly on the “big” names like AKB48, Momoiro Clover Z, Tokyo Girls’ Style, etc. Or to put it another way, AKS, Stardust and Avex.

    First let’s talk about management. We have AKS who are very good at marketing, but seriously lacking in actual promotion. In their case their marketing brings in huge numbers for singles and album sales by basically artificially inflating the number with the inclusion of autograph, handshake or 2-shot tickets. This makes the numbers for the analysts look great. A million seller single or album looks wonderful for things like Oricon and MTV and various records.

    The next factor we have to look at is Graduations, Shuffles, Elections and Janken tournaments. All of these cause fans and the public to talk, whether they are talking about how AKS is going to mess it up or how they can make everything perfect. It keeps the group(s) in the front of our minds and on the tip of everyone’s tongue.

    Combine these two factors together and you keep the media going gaga over you, which keeps you in front of the general public. So yes, in general AKS has excellent marketing at least for the general fans and general public.

    But what are the negative effects of their marketing? Well I can tell you from years of watching and enjoying AKS and Hello!Project, it gets really tiring after a while. The graduations are understandable and acceptable and while it’s always sad to see one of your favorite members leave in this industry it’s going to happen.

    Team Shuffles on the other hand are something I really don’t understand. Team A was the cool beauties, Team K was the awesome cool dancers with the powerful songs and Team B was the cute, basically traditional idols. Now what do the Teams have? Nothing. They have lost their marketing power when it comes to the teams. There is no identity there to sell other then some individual members which is not what you want when trying to sell something to the general fans.

    Now, shuffle concerts are absolutely amazing because you get to see members doing completely different songs. This is great for the general public because it adds a bit of freshness into the songs. The downside is that if you use members the general public isn’t familiar with then they tend to loose interest. However that is exactly what the hardcore fan is looking for, and you might just attract some of the casual fans to move a bit more to the hardcore side.

    Request Hours are basically a giant screw you. It has nothing to do with the quality of the song what so ever. It could be the best song in the world, but if it doesn’t have the hardcore fanbase’s favorite members it will never make it. The whole thing is nothing but a giant popularity contest for the members, which is exactly what it shouldn’t be. The Request Hour is probably one of the best marketing tools AKS has and the fans completely mess it up. It is our chance to tell Aki-P and management the type of songs we want to hear be it older style songs or more along the lines of “So Long” (please dear god no). Instead we change it into a member popularity contest which is something we already have.

    Elections, what can I say, the popularity contest #2. The election is one sided, great marketing but effectively pointless from the hardcore fans side because we all know who the top 16 are going to be. If Watanabe Mayu or Kashiwagi Yuki announced a graduation just before the election then I can almost promise that they would be #1 for the election. While if Takeuchi Miyu announced her graduation she might be lucky to get into the top 32 but still wouldn’t break the top 16. So it’s just another excuse for management to pat themselves on the back and tell themselves they are using the right members, because they are the only members the general public knows and votes for.

    The Janken tournament is amazing if it is solely based on random luck and not stacked or setup so that a certain girl wins. As long as it stays completely random it’s absolutely amazing for the fans, as we get the chance to see possibly completely unknown girls from any of the AKS groups. This is good for marketing because they can do the whole “Come see the possible upset of XXXX” angle. The fans also get to see some interesting and odd line ups, which is great for keeping things somewhat new and interesting.

    momoclolive

    Now let’s look at Stardust marketing. We have three groups we can look at here, but I won’t be focusing on Team Syachihoko because they haven’t been around long enough to establish any sort of real theme. Momoiro Clover Z has probably the best marketing you can get and it follows what I feel idols are meant to be. They don’t focus on the CDs as much, and primarily focus on their concerts, and they don’t even have to sell the concerts anymore. They tell you the title and where it’s going to be and you know exactly what to expect, be it at Zepp, Budoukan, or Nissan Stadium. They sell their concerts as a place to come enjoy some music and stupidity from the girls and release your stress and go away re-energized.

    Shiritsu Ebisu Chuugaku is a bit different because I feel they haven’t settled on only one style of concert. Most seem to follow a festival or play/musical theme and don’t seem to be as high energy as their big sisters but they still manage to make them interesting and worthwhile to see. I will say Stardust does need to take a look at Ebichu for some better marketing because they just don’t match up. Without something, be it CDs or concerts they aren’t going to be able to reach the heights Momoiro Clover has, but maybe they aren’t looking for another idol act.

    People are probably wondering why I haven’t talked about promotion at all yet. That’s because marketing is all about selling the brand, so let’s take the time to talk about promotion now.

    Promotion is the one area that AKS fails miserably in. You have 16 girls, that management says said are pretty enough, cute enough, funny enough, well spoken, or whatever reason it is to appear on TV. Then there are another 130 girls that aren’t worth having on TV. Now it’s true that the 16 is per group so the numbers aren’t exact, but what is the point of having all these other girls? Well it’s all about the idea of “Idols you can meet”. You’ve got 16 girls to promote interest in the group and get people to look into them, then another 130 girls to give the widest chance of them finding someone they will like and stay interesting in. This is all great in theory but in practice it doesn’t work out as well as it should.

    ske48live

    First we have the mass graduation from SKE. A lot of the members who left during the mass graduation were well known members. Maybe not all were in that top 16 slot but you knew them, like Kuwabara Mizuki for example. Whether you loved her or hated her you knew who she was. Then we have someone like Yagami Kumi who was actually one of the front members of SKE. The problem we run into here is that management, while they did a pretty good job of promoting the top 16-20 members, they just had at least 6 of their top tier to top-mid tier members leave. This happened without management ever promoting or pushing some of the lower tier members and preparing them to step into those vacant spots. So they spent time scrambling to figure out who to add to those top 16 spots to fill in on TV shows.

    Let’s take a minute to look at this a bit more in depth. We’ll do this by looking at SKE and NMB. Now as foreign fans we don’t get the chance to go to the theater and seem them nearly as much as we would like to. Instead we have to rely on the internet and TV to show us the members. This means we are basically regulated to what the general public gets to see. We get to see the top 16, and maybe a select 8-12 from AKB only. From SKE and NMB we might see the top 4-6 members. That still leaves a whole lot of members that we may very rarely see or never see. They need TV shows to promote the members to the general public but they can’t afford to promote 130 girls on TV at one time. They have to pick and choose, and that is fine for the shows where they are guests and can just send those top 16. The question is, why can’t we have a rotating schedule for shows like “AKBingo”, “AKB Show” and “SKE48 Gakuin”? Why can’t we have a show like AKB48+10 where they introduced us to all of Team B and their various quirks and personalities. “SKE48 Gakuin”, “AKBingo”, “AKB to XX” and “Nemosou” are perfect platforms to showcase the lower tier members.

    hkt48live

    Yabuki Nako appeared on “HKT48 no Odekake” and did nothing but smile and blush and whisper maybe a dozen words and everyone went gaga over her. I’ll be the first to admit that some members just aren’t suitable for TV but that’s fine, show us that. Put them on TV and show us they suck. You never know, we might like them more because of it if they are good in front of an audience but not TV. I understand that they want the ratings and that’s why they put the more popular members on TV but you know what, it was more interesting watching Team 4 old and new challenge “AKBingo” than it was seeing the same old members all the time on it. You can’t tell me that putting lesser known members on the show hurt, because they had the same or higher ratings which means it’s not the general public that is watching AKBingo. It’s the hardcore fans watching it.

    Now I’m sure some of you are thinking “But what about Mio and Meru?” Well HKT is different and it’s always been this way when they create a new group. There is 1 or 2 kenkyuusei who are pushed because they are going to be big in either the current or new team. Sadly when it comes to the secondary teams be it K2, E, M, B2, K4, whatever, if it isn’t the main team all but 1 or 2 members get ignored with AKB being the exception. Then you watch concerts like the Dome tour and see some girl and go “She’s awesome, who is she?”

    Lets take a look at a couple of girls, Kobayashi Kana and Tanabe Miku. Kobayashi, a 2nd generation member and Team K original, has only ranked once in the election at 41st place, was in a few of the earlier singles, appeared only a few times on the various shows and very rarely appears now. When she did appear originally she was funny and silly and added to the show but in recent appearances she just doesn’t appear to care but can still be funny when she wants.

    Tanabe is a 3rd generation member and Team B original who I believe has appeared on even less singles and TV shows than Kobayashi has. I think she is funnier than Kobayashi though and more willing to look like an idiot to get a laugh. I’ve spent a lot of time wondering why girls like Kobayashi and Tanabe have stayed with AKB for so long, clearly there is a reason but we don’t know what.

    NMB and SKE are basically in the same spot that Kobayashi and Tanabe are in. Team N and Team S get promoted but the other 4 teams are practically ignored and we may never see the possibilities that those teams hold in their members. Of course some of you might be thinking, but it’s not up to AKS to promote the girls on TV and you would be wrong. NMB members are part of the Yoshimoto Kyaraku agency, SKE members are part of the Pythagoras agency while HKT members are all AKS. AKB is a bit different with the most popular members being parts of big agencies like Ota Pro, Watanabe Pro, HoriPro, but most of the new members are part of AKS.

    For NMB we can lay some of the blame on Yoshimoto for not promoting the members of M and B2 but also AKS for not involving them in more AKB48 Group TV shows. With SKE it’s not exactly clear who is managing them be it Pythagoras or AKS, but whatever the case, the management team behind SKE needs to take a long, hard look at things. HKT like I said is with AKS and so far they have done pretty good with HKT but they probably just haven’t gotten to the point yet where they only show a select few members and ignore the rest because they are still a young group.

    So what does this all mean in the end? It means that while the older and popular members continue to graduate, they aren’t doing enough to promote new members to replace them and keep the general public interested in the group. Sooner or later the members are going to see the lack of promotion and interest and like any employee in any business that isn’t getting the recognized they are going to leave because they can do their current activities without being tied to the group. Be it modeling, acting, or whatever, some of the girls might even feel like they are being pushed to leave because they aren’t allowed to do some things, or from the simple fact they are being ignored. It’s my personal opinion that SKE will be the first hit hard by this.

    To recap, marketing is excellent overall while promotion is a large failure overall.

    stardust

    So that’s AKS, now let’s take a look at Stardust Management, the ones in charge of Momoiro Clover Z, Shiritsu Ebisu Chuugaku, and the newly formed Team Syachihoko, and Takoyaki Rainbow. What do they do so differently?

    First let’s look at marketing, or should we say the lack of marketing. At least when it comes to singles and albums. There’s no handshake tickets, no 2-shot tickets, no autograph tickets, if you’re lucky you might get a free picture with your CD. DVDs and Blu-rays normally come with some sort of concert photo collection, but you aren’t getting anything that would make you want to buy multiply copies unless you are one of those that wants to collect all the different cover arts. That alone isn’t going to make you buy hundreds of copies like AKS does though.

    They don’t even have TV shows really. Ebichu has a short 2 minute show called “Ebi-land” which is similiar to “DERA SKE”, and I believe Syachihoko has a local Nagoya TV show. Momoclo does have “Momoclo-chan” on TV Asahi which for a long time was web only and I believe is now airing weekly on TV, but nothing like AKS does with it’s dozen of TV shows and appearances every week.

    Stardust marketing revolves around live performances more than anything as that is where the Stardust groups really shine, with each major concert being a unique experience.

    Now some of you are probably saying “But they make fans buy singles to get handshakes at events!”, but there is a major difference with the smaller idol groups and indie groups doing this and what AKS does with selling tickets included in their CDs. Selling them at events doesn’t inflate the numbers that appear in the rankings. If Oricon says Momoclo sold 90,000 copies of their latest single then that is how many sold in major retailers like HMV and Tower Records, as those sold at events are not counted any longer for Oricon at least. So even though they may be using the same type of tactics, they aren’t getting the numbers for it.

    Promotion for Stardust is also vastly different from AKS, and shares more similarities to what Avex does with Tokyo Girls’ Style. With internet live streams of the members chatting and talking about various events and happenings to small lives at Tower Records and HMV and even personally packaging and handing out CDs at release events, again at Tower and HMV stores. You also get things like bus tours through Akihabara with the girls explaining details about their newest single or whatever over a PA system as they drive through the area or areas. Generally special events like that have special free lives at the end of the tour. The real difference with Stardust promotion is a lot of actors, comedians, TV announcers are fans of at least Momoclo and will do special runs on morning shows, where I don’t see a lot of big names going on about AKS groups. This is in addition to the music shows they appear on.

    ebichu

    Now we’ll look at the music. As an idol fan you’ve probably said “I’m not into idols for the music, I’m in it for the girls.” Well that’s just not true, and yes I can hear you yelling now that it’s true and I’ll tell you again that it’s not true. Let’s take a look at what an idol is. There are two parts to an Idol, the first being that we want to cheer and support the members in reaching their dreams, be that singing, acting, modeling, or something completely outside of the entertainment field. At the same time we want to be cheered and support by the members. For some, going to an idol concert might be akin to going to the spa, where they come back refreshed and ready to take on the world.

    So the music is important or idols wouldn’t be doing it. The music picks us up after a hard days work and lets us forget about the stresses of life. Now that doesn’t mean it has to be great music, or that the music has to follow any particular genre. I will say personally that when idols start taking themselves too seriously or get too professional is when I start loosing interest in them. Morning Musume was that way, when they started being serious and professional on TV shows I started loosing interest in the members. I still liked the music but even that started waning after a few singles, at least until recently. I’m enjoying the sound from H!P currently, and while the members can be serious and professional when need be, they don’t act that way all the time and even say some things that I don’t feel were acceptable to management even a year ago.

    Again, the music is important and when our favorite idols release a bad song it’s okay to say so. It’s not the members fault 99% of the time, people like Aki-P and Tsunku are not perfect and it’s okay to call them out on it. Let’s be honest, we are here to support the girls and I’d like to think the girls are here for us too. Yes Akimoto and Tsunku or whoever is bringing them to us, but we are the ones paying for their lifestyles and at least in the case of H!P and AKS/AKB48 Group, if we don’t express our displeasure with what they are doing, then sooner or later people will get upset and leave or simply get bored and stop paying attention. Then our favorite members are going to disappear along with the groups.

    So why am I bringing this up while talking about music? Because music is where the majority of the money and focus is, but nothing says that is the way it has to be. I see no reason why we couldn’t have comedy corners during concerts, or VTRs during costume and set changes voiced by the members. There are so many other things they could do during concerts or shows to show off the various members hobbies, talents, skills or quirks.

    Since we’re on the subject, why not talk about members, not specific members but just overall.

    dempagumiinc

    This is also where we will start comparing the differences in idol groups.

    We’ll just name a few groups and look at them, we’ve got AKB family, Momoiro Clover (Momoclo), Shiritsu Ebisu Chuugaku (Ebichu), Dempagumi Inc. Tokyo Girls Style (TGS), 9nine and Passpo. These are some of the groups I’ll be referring to in the following sections.

    How about starting with personality? Every member has a different personality, this is what they show on various TV shows. These are the things that are harder to cover with their character. Bits and pieces of who they really are behind the idol image, but it’s also part of their character’s personality, like Okada Nana’s majime or serious personality. Sometimes it’s hard to tell just how much is real personality and what’s character, like Takamina and not bathing with members is I believe real personality, whatever the reason is be it modesty or she doesn’t like looking at naked girls or whatever. Personality is also something that is shown while performing, like Nishino Miki who is going all out during performances.

    Unfortunately I think management would rather have a perfect dance/singing performance than one personalized by the members performing it and this is where shuffle concerts and performances suffer for AKB. They tend not to show a lot of personal personality during them, and really only show off during the big all member performances. I would much rather see more ad-lib and personality than a perfect performance.

    On the other hand Momoclo, Ebichu, Dempagumi and 9nine from what I’ve seen (which I admit for Dempagumi and 9nine is not much), would much rather personalize each performance than have a technically perfect performance. Some even emphasize not being anywhere near perfect, which for me is absolutely perfect. I don’t want my idols to be so stressed about putting on a perfect performance that they can’t have fun doing it. As I see it, if you can’t have fun as an entertainer then you should probably find something else because if you aren’t enjoying doing it your audience isn’t going to enjoy watching it.

    Now as for character, we have in some cases two different characters. One for the group and the character of the members, or even the character of the song. For example, Passpo has the character of flight attendants while Momoclo has this Sentai/Power Rangers/Wrestling character in a lot of their songs and performances.

    Momoclo is a great example of member character, like you have Sasaki Ayaka as the idol character always trying to be cute and happy and silly. AKB you have Kojima Haruna with the sexy character, Tano Yuka and Oshima Ryoka with the kusogaki character and Ota Aika who had the tsundere character. A character does not make an Idol but sometimes it’s a certain character type that attracts a certain type of fan and that is what they come to handshake events for. A character also helps them to showcase and sometimes steal the spotlight on TV.

    Character is needed but I feel it should be a natural extension of the members personalities, forced character just becomes uncomfortable and awkward on TV. It’s true that sometimes it works out, but a natural character just has a better flow to it. This is something that AKS does well and not so well at the same time. Some of the girls have strong characters that naturally come through and strengthen over time, while other girls don’t really have any specific character type and these are the ones that tend to be less popular.

    Some of this is also why the AKS shuffles are good and bad. The good being if you shuffle it right, you might get girls who seem to lack character mixed with other girls that they have more in common with or less in common with which they can feed off of and show more character traits. At the same time this is also the bad part as they may feel stifled by the girls they are now surrounded with and they end up falling in popularity.

    This is where groups like Momoclo and Ebichu tend to shine through, the members have been around each other for so long that they know how each is going to react and they know what to say to get certain reactions. This is just one of the main benefits of having a smaller group, you get a much more intimate feel between the members.

    tokyogirlsstyle

    The other side of the coin is TGS, they don’t really have characters for themselves. Personality sure, everyone does but they also don’t classify themselves as an idol group but as a dance and vocal group. The fans see them more as an idol group though, and they have been to Tokyo Idol Festival, so by the industry they are an Idol group. From an agency standpoint that might not be the case, and while Nakae Yuri might be viewed as the comedian of the group it’s not a fully blown character that is pushed and developed.

    Well if you’ve stuck around this long I’m surprised and if you aren’t pissed me at this point I’m also impressed. Now let’s continue on to something that I find odd about the idol industry.

    Let’s go into skill and talent, some may see these as being one and the same, but they are two very separate things. Skill is something that can be learned and practiced and even mastered. Talent is something that comes naturally, that once discovered you have a natural adaption for, be it singing, dancing or playing piano. However just because you are talented doesn’t mean you have the skill to use that talent, but it does mean you can generally learn the skills and master it easier.

    So you ask why I bring this up when talking about idols who have had a somewhat notorious reputation in lacking talent, and even skill? Well let’s just name a few names, Moriyasu Madoka, Azuma Rion, Matsui Sakiko, Takeuchi Miyu and Masuda Yuka. Now lets look at some data.

    Azuma Rion, excellent piano player be it skilled or natural talent, said to have perfect pitch, in the last election didn’t rank, but that really isn’t surprising as she only debuted 3 months before the election. She is getting recognized, be it for her skills or personality I can’t really say.

    Takeuchi Miyu, 9th gen member, skilled piano player, pretty good singer, trained in classic ballet, has been in 4 of 5 senbatsu elections and never ranked, and only been in senbatsu twice.

    Matsui Sakiko, 7th gen members, talented piano player, has been in all 5 elections, the first 2 she never ranked, her highest rank is 38th in the 3rd election, after that 53rd and 60th.

    Moriyasu Madoka, 1st gen HKT member, skilled at least if not talented piano player, from what I’ve heard a quality singer, was in the last 2 elections, never ranked but not really surprising.

    Masuda Yuka, 2nd gen Ex-AKB member, talented singer, appeared only 5 times in senbatsu, out of the 4 elections she got senbatsu once with a rank of 20th, and undergirls the other 3 ranking 25th and 26th.

    Why do I bring up specific examples? Well because skilled and talented girls are under utilized. Just look at HKT48, Tashima Meru, Tomonaga Mio, even Miyawaki Sakura are barely passable singers, but they are the ones put in as the aces and faces of the group. Even Itano Tomomi is a barely passable singer which is why all her singles are so heavily auto tuned. Then you have girls who you would expect to be weak or even terrible singers and they turn out to be pretty decent singers like Akiyoshi Yuka (HKT48) and Hirota Aika (Ebichu) who sounds like she’s 5 when speaking, can sound like she’s 5 singing, and then suddenly breaks out in this voice that is astonishing.

    On to the point and this comes back to what I said earlier. We don’t want professionals for idols, we want amateurs people who are flawed, who make mistakes. I think this is why management pushes those girls with lower skills or talents, and why the fans don’t pick up the more talented and skilled members for them to be massive popular members.

    Now lets switch tracks here and go to Momoclo where people complain because they “can’t sing”. Why is it that people complain Momoclo can’t sing, yet AKS has demonstrated that several dozen of their members are barely passable and they get huge popularity out of it. I won’t argue that Momoclo are the best singers because they aren’t. They aren’t talented singers but they are skilled to a decent to good level. They do lack some technically in their singing but that isn’t why people say they can’t sing. They say it because they have a really hard time dancing and singing, where AKB gets nice auto tuned studio recordings to play during 95% of their lives. Momoclo uses maybe 5-10% studio recordings and when given the chance to sing without the high energy dancing they are quiet good singers.

    kanakojump

    So I guess this brings us to our conclusion, how can a group that sells 80-100,000 achieve the same level as a group that sells millions every single? Lets just look at that for a second here.

    I made a point that I believe is a key factor to being an idol group earlier “release your stress and go away re-energized”. This is what it all boils down to really, be it in concert, handshake events, 2-shots, or whatever other event a group does.

    Not always does this refer to the fans, it could refer to the idols as well. This has been documented though where an idol has said something to a fan and changed their outlook on something, and though I don’t have any proof I’m sure there have been some idols who have had their fans tell them something that has changed their outlook as well.

    This is the whole basis for being an idol or idol fan, the idol supporting the fan however directly or indirectly and the idol fan supporting the idol.

    Now back to the key, and where it really comes out and that’s at the concerts or lives, here is something to think about. What is the turn over rate for an AKB concert? How many of the people who attend are casual fans who might go to 1 or 2 concerts? I’m sure it’s high but honestly I don’t think this is something that has ever been researched. I say this because even though I would consider myself a hardcore fan, in the last couple years I’ve found most of the 48Group concerts to be very lackluster and frankly boring, and i would never want to buy an election DVD. The election is boring to watch. The Janken tournament at least has some suspense in it, and it’s interesting to see the outfits that the girls choose to wear, but I’m not sure I would ever want to watch it more than once or twice.

    I understand that watching the shows live is completely different, but I can’t think that their shows are all that much fun even live, and I’m not sure after 2 or 3 shows I would really want to go back. I also realized something else, I wouldn’t want to see any idol group at a large venue like Tokyo Dome or Nissan Stadium, simply because I would be so far away I couldn’t see them clearly.

    If we take a look at Momoclo, this will tell you why I had nothing nice to say about AKB here.

    Momoclo concerts are in one word “Godlike”. I could sit down and watch any of their shows from 2010 to now and be entertained. All of their shows are interesting and unique. They don’t have any of the “we are going to stand in this spot and sing” thing going on. They are always running around or dancing in different areas, running into or up to the crowd, basically there is nothing standard about their performances. It’s also different because the girls have a hand in creating what they are performing, be it songs or events. If you look at just how much goes into each major Momoclo concert, be it money or effect, you can see a huge difference. Perhaps this is one of the benefits of being a small group, you can put more of your time and money into the experience and less into the members.

    tokyodome

    For 48G everything is standardized and very static except for the member performing the song. Outfits are shared and there are little to no stage props. While I can understand this because it allows them to throw just about any member into a song and not have to do a lot of practice once they know the dance, but this ends up being dull after a while. Now I’ll admit the Tokyo Dome City Hall concert (the 3 graduation one), had interesting stage design and some good stage props but it’s pretty rare for them to do that.

    The other factor here is that Momoclo doesn’t try to be something it’s not. They know not to take themselves too seriously, and maybe it’s that frank honesty that has attracted the industry talent that has put themselves behind Momoclo. I think it’s also the lack of gimmicks in their CDs, and just the genuine nature of the girls and their music that has drawn in such a wide variety of fans for Momoclo. You’ve got everyone from the 80-year old grandma and grandpa to the 4-year old kids going to their concerts, I’m pretty sure we can’t say the same for 48G.

    So the tl:dr of how Momoclo reached the same stage as AKB 3 years earlier than AKB is fun, variety, and being genuine in who and what they are.

     
    If you read this far, you might as well leave a comment and let us know your thoughts!

    About Charlie Cowdin

    Check Also

    Episode Recap: Odekake Ep 218 (5.25.17)

    HKT48のおでかけ! Air Date: 5/25/2017 Rating 8/10 This is the second part of the show from …

    24 comments

    1. Came here for the MCZ, stumbled through midway and got Kanako’d in the last quarter. Would’ve rather read how each group handles their own brand marketing – like a Market Study of sorts. The images helped break the spirit but not the pace.

      • I wouldn’t mind doing this, but I’m not sure what to focus on exactly. If you have some ideas I’m willing to look into it.

    2. I enjoyed reading this.

      I’m not a big fan of the 48 groups just for the fact that there are too many girls and I’m very ocd about things and I like to know what each girl has to offer before making my mind up on supporting the group and one/some of their members.

      I’m also note interested in the music as I don’t understand Japanese and finding sub’s of full programs is long and boring for me.

      I did try to get into AKB but got bored of how stale the group was in terms of promoting members. I also got annoyed that their top members could get away with anything but their lower ranked members were made to leave for doing the same thing.

      I also get very annoyed with their lack of live singing. Something I read somewhere tried to justify the groups lip syncing buy saying that it was easier for the members where were really busy but I never brought it as if Morning Musume during their golden era could perform live with little to no lip syncing then why can’t the 48 groups do it?

      Sorry for making this comment long. I’ll stop there.

    3. Great article Drako60!! You deserve a star!! :D

      I do feel kind of sorry for AKB and it’s sister groups, I mean, they have become a victim of their own success and it has created a selection of vicious circles for them(mainly thanks to what I think is basically arrogance on their management front) in which they are stuck choosing the same members because they want to remain popular, they want to keep selling a million with every single and for all the reasons like that.

      And this creates situations in which it’s hard to place new members into those main roles, either in the way SKE had to, where loosing multiple top and mid-top members forced them to put in members who, at the time, were not promoted to “Senbatsu levels” into their Senbatsu or like AKB where putting new girls into Senbatsu is almost like placing an alien on the stage with the other girls because it’s something different and in the confines of AKB, that is something strange indeed…..

      I think the whole popularity things, like you said is effecting concerts too, I mean I honestly can’t remember the last AKB concert I have overly enjoyed or even really been overly excited about, there are at this point pretty much carbon copies of each other, hell even the graduation concerts during the dome tour were only different for about 5-10% I mean they are still good and have their moments but, yeah, I guess I just feel a bit jaded by them…..

      Of course this is not helped by Momoclo where before a concert you wonder what special guest might turn up, what Magic tricks Reni might do, if a circus troupe will turn up to entertain you during a break for the girls, if Momoka might ride her bike near you, if they decide that a football match is a good idea or not or if a dinosaur will come out on stage or not, for a simple comparison I suggest people go watch both groups performances in the Nissan Stadium, I think it speaks for itself…. (and why I’m much more excited for Momoclo in the Olympic Stadium over AKB)

      As for Momoclo to me their greatest asset is that I just love watching them, there are no worries, I don’t worry about if my favorite members are well featured, I don’t worry about if they will get a good shuffle unit or not, I don’t worry about what songs will be sung I don’t worry about where the girls will rank, I just look forward to seeing them go out a perform and be themselves, it’s just a very refreshing (and enjoyable) experience

      I do love the 48 groups and anyone who half knows me (or at least which idols I like) knows that

    4. I’m surprised that in such a lengthy article you didn’t touch on one key difference between Stardust and AKS/HelloPro, namely that Stardust idols don’t do photobooks or bikinis. Stardust seems to emphasize charismatic, high energy girls with little care for their physical appearance. I mean, is there even one attractive girl in Team Syachihoko?

      Anecdotally, I travel to Japan a lot for work, and while none of my colleagues or acquaintances are idol fans at all, I am always struck by how much they hate AKB and how they have overwhelmingly positive feelings for Momoclo. Senbatsu election results and graduations do get discussed, so score one for AKS marketing, but everyone is completely unimpressed with AKB selling a million records. All they talk about is how wasteful the fans are for buying dozens of CDs for event tickets and tossing the CDs aside. And while they may be more likely to name an AKB song than a Momoclo song, they are completely aware of Momoclo’s live reputation and even say they would like to see them in concert one day because it looks like so much fun.

      On the other hand, even the AKB haters have their favorite girls they lust after, whereas Momoclo are seen as plain girls you wouldn’t recognize on the street. Nevertheless, people keep saying that Momoclo is the top idol in Japan and AKB is done. This is obviously wishful thinking more than anything else, but it probably shows that there is a lot of room for growth for Momoclo, whereas AKB’s audience is what it is. The positive feelings for Momoclo among people who don’t really pay attention to idols is quite striking. I’m not sure how Stardust has managed to pull this off. Maybe Momoclo is just a unique case.

      Incidentally, I never hear anyone talk about Morning Musume or any other group.

      • Momoclo was voted the #1 Idol group 2013 in japan by the public, but the media and industry still say AKB is #1 based on sales, I’ll be interested to see what happens when all of Momoclo are out of high school.

        Morning Musume i could nearly write a complete dissertation on them alone, they are a unique beast that quite frankly I’m not sure how they have survived.

        • Don’t know much about Japanese culture but do you think the reason why the general public are much more favorable toward MCZ as opposed to the 48 groups is a combination of
          – MCZ not doing gravure and any shoots bikini’s or raunchy clothing? (though I thought Japan had no problem with them)

          -AKB having hundreds of girls? (possible quality>quantity thinking)
          -Momoclo having unique songs with unique lyrics that aren’t the typical idol songs? especially since a lot of Akmioto songs revolve around young love.
          -AKB numerous scandals since being the public eye?
          -Being a juggernaught in sales for 3+ years (jealousy? not good enough for their sales?)
          -AKB48 considered only to having a wota fanbase….?

          I follow both groups though I follow AKB more, even though I’m not at all surprised that MCZ has a better reputation to the public. Outside of the fanbase it probably gets harder and harder to keep a good image the longer time goes on, and with all the top members that the public only care about leaving it’ll probably get worse for them.

          • I don’t know about the gravure/bikini photos having an effect. More i think it’s just the complete mass of media being shoved everywhere they can get , over exposure and saturation after a while you just get tired of it.

            The number of girls certainly has an effect, it can be an overwhelming aspect to getting into the group, also the fact that the songs for the last 3 years have been the same, it get’s stale after a while.

            I can’t say for sure how the scandals affect the public image of the group, I would like to think that the scandals mostly affect the hardcore fans, and that’s why they choose to do the votes they’ve done in the past at handshake events. Honestly I don’t know though.

            Having something unique about you is certainly a benefit, be it songs, lyrics, dance, or whatever. if AKS released more songs like Darkness, Escape, or Kimi no koto ga suki dakara, I think they would probably do better.

            This is why I said we need the Request Hour to be what it’s meant to be, a showing of the songs we like, not the members, if we can show them we don’t like the songs they are releasing, maybe we can get them to change.

      • There are attractive girls in Team Syachihoko. Akimoto Honoka, Sakamoto Haruna, and Sakura Nao.

      • All of the girls in Syachihoko are beautiful. (But Team Syachihoko is my favorite group so I’m biased). Sakura Nao, Itou Chiyuri and Akimoto Honoka are very traditionally attractive, and I’m very partial to Yuzuki’s appearance (though that’s because I’m Yuzuki oshi so)

    5. Momoclo are ok singers for their genre but its mostly the tone and the members vocals color that gets on peoples nerves (high piched/chlidlike) besides Momoka (Green). Kaneko (Red) was the main one that people had issues with but her singing has improved a tonne in the past year and is now probably the best in the group technically. Though Momoka will always have the preferred voice because of its tone in comparison to Kaneko who probably has the highest voice in the group.

      Thing is though, like you brought up they barely use any backing track and even when they do its a miniscule amount. You can ALWAYS clearly hear their voices to the point where I question if the staff turned the mic volume up before Momoclo is on, but its just that their vocals aren’t drowned out at all. Even when their voices are literally dieing from strain they give it their all even though that’s incredibly unhealthy to do so but I appreciate the effort.

      As opposed to the 48 groups, they are the complete opposite in that they almost always lip-sync, the only time they don’t is on very special occasions or during theater, but even then its not always and its only a certain few members. I understand the bad singers don’t want to be embarrassed but I doubt wotas care, in fact they’ll probably enjoy the struggle. Plus it’d be hard to get better at singing if one never sings, even without vocal training you could learn about the bad singing habits you might do, find your comfort zone, improve your stamina and pick up a few good things from the good singers in the group if this happens regularly. Especially with a large group of people harmonizing is important, and with no practice it can sound like a mess when the group does have to perform live (kouhaku etc). My idea would be to start small and have theater shows ALL live, cause its mostly hardcore wotas and they won’t care if you sound like a castrated water buffalo. For concerts have the confident and competent or brave members sing, basically give them the choice too.

      In regards to management

      With the 48 groups it seems as though THEY pick and choose who they are gonna push regardless of who the fans want to see. Which I find very odd, if there are girls that are liked by the fans and either get a high election score or high handshake tickets I would think that the smarter thing to do would be to push these girls to please the fans.

      Not naming names but there are some girls being heavily pushed for years and no one cares yet they still keep doing so, there are also girls that weren’t that popular before their big push but are now so technically it worked which is okay I guess, but their are girls that aren’t pushed at all yet are popular or well liked by fans but management decide that pushing those girls are a no-no, though sometimes they can actually do good (3 musketeers etc) but that doesn’t elude the fact that their have been a lot of missed oppurtunities.

      I don’t get it. I’m guessing possible outside connections and affiliations might have something to do with it, probably puts them on a higher priority…..still kind of shitty though, and I wonder if the support these talent companies provide be better than the increased amount of wota money and future brand strength that a pre-pushed popular fan favorite girls can give once she is pushed as much as some other girls.

    6. Didn’t have the chance to say thank you for this great article before, so thank you :)

      If there’s anything to improve from it, it’s the in depth view of how stardust agency works. How the girls got auditioned, how the girls been trained to have that kind of stamina for concerts, who work on their music, how the girls don’t work in school day, how they keep the girls image clean, etc

      Another side of Momoclo which is untouched in this article is their variety skill. Which I think is the best among all idol groups. It’s how they got celebrities fans.

      About the other stardust’s group, to make it simple relative to Momoclo, Ebichu have better vocal, Syachi are like Momoclo on sugar rush everytime.

      Again, thank you for the good read.

    7. Great and balanced article!

      I think one of the main things that keeps Momoclo in the spotlight is they are not a “graduation” group. Fans can emotionally invest in the girls history and personality knowing they will not “graduate” and disappear from the face of the earth if something goes wrong. Ayaka Sasaki’s foot injury is a great example of this.

      Secondly, Momoclo is not “slutty” like the other idol groups. This makes them more respectable and fans of all ages are more likely to be publicly associated with them. This is what allows major talents like Marty Friedman and miwa to collaborate with them.
      Momoclo ventured into the “slutty” phase for a brief period with Kimi to Sekai and Coco☆Natsu but quickly distanced themselves from that model.
      I believe this is what also ended Mono Moni. They were doing great until they switched from cute/fun outfits to the skimpy ones of the “Lucky Cha Cha Cha” period.

      Third, personality and character. Team Syachihoko is a HUGE example of this. They are far from the most “beautiful” idols but people like them anyways. Honoka’s bat ears, Yuzu’s massive overbite and Haruna’s off-center eye would be a death sentence for traditional idols, especially selling outside Japan, but the combination just somehow “works” so that its hard to not enjoy watching them.

      • Hayami Akari left Momoclo. It’s not impossible that someone else might leave too.

        Mini Moni’s started off selling around 700k for Mini Moni Jankenpyon in 2001 to selling 29k for Mini Moni Kazoe no Uta in 2003. I think this reflects Hello Project’s own decline. I’d say Crazy about you was the greatest departure from their original image costume, dance and song. It sold 36k. Lucky Cha Cha Cha still had the skimpy costumes, but sounded cute. Sales dropped to 34k. As far as I can tell the result of the image change was a slight increase in sales. Mini Moni ended when Mika Todd went back to America.

    8. Interesting Stuff!
      As a Team Syachihoko fan, I think their biggest thing that sets them apart is that they’re from Nagoya. I mean, that’s pretty obvious, but they really emphasize their origin in a lot of stuff. Their first national major single, Shuto Iten Keikaku, was all about how Japan should change its capitol to Nagoya instead of Tokyo. In Ai no Chikyuusai, their next single, there’s a line that mentions Aichi prefecture. Their name references back to Nagoya, and their main shout “Miso katsu! Tebasaki! Ebifry!” references food from Nagoya. They have two main TV shows – Yurusyachi (Their variety thing) and Nagoya Syachihoko Gakuen, which is basically a travelogue that shows off various aspects of Nagoya.
      Beyond that, though, they’re basically the energetic and high-powered group of the bunch, at this point. MomoClo used to have very high-powered lives, but I think they haven’t quite been as good as they used to be.
      It is true, though, that live events are really where these groups shine. While with other groups I watch concerts sporadically, I buy every Syachihoko blu-ray set and it’s always a very worthwhile purchase. Their latest set had two concerts on it and both were interesting, unique, and a lot of fun.

      I don’t think I’m quite as critical of AKB as you are; they DID spur the current idol boom, and I’m grateful for that. There are also event tickets in Stardust CDs; I know that for Ai no Chikyuu sai there was a chance to go to a karaoke event, for example (which got livestreamed and was incredibly fun). And I think that while not every girl is promoted as much in 48 (which is kind of understandable) that they’ve been doing a fairly good job of promoting the newer generations of girls. I mean, look at where girls like Paruru, Kawaei Rina and Kojima Mako are!
      I think there’s a lot of good to the Stardust model. I consider myself a Stardust fan; Team Syachihoko is my idol group of choice, and I’m really excited to see where Takoyaki Rainbow is going. But I don’t think that AKB should be discounted; they have a really solid model right now, and without AKB I doubt MomoClo would have hit the heights they’ve hit so far.

    9. Didn’t quite understand the article’s title until the end, haha. Great write up, Drako. This is the greatest thing you’ve written in the year 2014. Trololol.

      In all seriousness though, I like what I see. The flow could be better, but whatever we aren’t pros, etc. I like all the points you bring up and you give me new perspective on Momoiro Clover.

      I also really dig the interaction and in-depth comments we’re getting here. Thanks everyone for chiming in!

      As for my 2 cents, I did see AKB48 at Tokyo Dome and SKE48 at Kobe World Hall and although they were large concerts, I think much of the experience was influenced by the fans. Of course, you can argue the same with Momoclo and I respect that. You know I get my jollies from AKB48 the most so Tokyo Dome 2012 day 3 was ultra special for me. I also think AKS/48G spends quite a bit on the production of their concerts (the stages they built for TDC2012, Manatsu no Dome Tour, Seibu Dome, SSA, etc).

      I can also definitely see the reasons why Momoclo would appeal more in an innocent, fun, energetic, young girls way. The business models are also quite different. 48G’s overhead is a bit nuts, and you covered that with the whole quality vs quantity argument, which is still a common one brought up in today’s H!P vs. 48G Cold War. And of course, the 48G has been at the top for a while now, they want to maintain status quo with the least amount of risks as possible so it’s definitely easy to pick apart their model.

      Regardless, good on Momoclo for getting as far as they have. If they can give AKB48 a run for its money, we all benefit! :)

    10. Overall a good read, just one part I have a problem with…
      You seem to think that the appeal of idols is only the girls, and dismiss the music as just another part of the marketing scheme to push cute girls. As a person who is into idols primarily for the music, I dislike this change in the idol industry/community that has largely been brought on by AKB’s popularity. Don’t get me wrong, idols were always about cute girls, but cute girls that had musical skill and high quality music to back it. Of course the level of skill needed has dropped significantly since the 70’s and 80’s, but I don’t even have a problem when the girls aren’t skilled performers, where I draw the line is when idol companies think it’s okay to release terrible music because people will buy it for the girls anyhow. I hate this idea that singles are just worthless cds with a handshake ticket, and rather than the quality of the product, the fans would rather play a counting game comparing sales numbers.

      As for Momoclo vs. AKB, a huge difference between them is the quality of the music. Where as lately AKB’s music is a hit or miss (but mostly a miss), Momoclo consistently has music with good composition and variety while still having an energy to their music that’s very “idol”.

      Unrelated note: Now I remember why I never comment on stuff, because it takes me hours to write a single paragraph. I only stopped writing this out of frustration, but I have a lot more I want to say, meh…oh well.

      • I have to agree it’s not a good thing that the music is a marketing scheme now.

        Sadly the fans seem to believe if you aren’t supporting the music then you aren’t supporting the girls, so the producers namely Aki-p and Tsunku come to mind, are able to push out worse and worse music and still get the sales because of this mind set.

        One of my biggest pet peeves with the 48G is that they tend to put the least musically talented members in the center with the most lines. The only reason I can see for this is because they have bigger personalities or more out going personalities.

        I’m pretty sure I’ll be touching on a lot of this in an upcoming series of articles.

    11. A good post. I’m not sure about the singing for both groups but Momoclo does seem to be more easier to get into especially performance and personality wise.

      http://nynyonline.co.uk

    12. I’m quite fazed at the idea of making comparison between AKB48 and Momoiro Clover Z. I mean they are both idol group but with entirely different concept. Its quite hard to put it in writing but allow me to try. Warning: I’m a fan of AKB48, more like use to be but still is at a degree.

      Back in 2010, I did have the chance to listen to Momoiro Clover’s debut single “Ikuze! Kaitō Shōjo” and I do admit I enjoy it but at the same time felt its a bit detach to the norm, which at the time was the Morning Musume style, since I used to be a MM fan until Koha graduate.

      I already have known AKB48 way back Iiwake Maybe but they really are a pain to follow having so many members but having RIVER as #1 really touch off a wave of curiosity but Ponytail to Shushu and Heavy Rotation was un-watchable for being too erotic to the innocent me back in the days. But BEGINNER was just awesome I didn’t have a chance to look at Pinky Jones, and that’s the end of my short honeymoon with Momoiro Clover.

      I can’t speak much about Momoclo but I can digest AKB with a bit confidence.

      AKB48’s promotion strategy isn’t really a let down, its a build upon tactics upon tactics in their long journey to stardom. If we look at its history, AKS used almost all possible methodology to promote the concept to the public (MVP, tour bus guide, flyers and etc.) and it took them almost 4 long years to get #1 in the charts, and it was Aki-P’s last straw as Acchan has already graduate or probably graduating High school by that time and it would be quite difficult to market the school concept of the group have they failed that chance.

      AKB48’s success in the charts is build upon the events they have patented. First, when they did the first election it didn’t really help much with the sale but it promotes them heavily by having the public remember them as the only group having a selection event for single appearance. Second, one of the reason for RIVER hitting #1 was its voting ticket for Request Hour 2010. I think the fact that the Team B fans manage to pulled off a miraculous number 1 in 2009 AX must have prompted the idea of morphing this event much more into a fan voting battle instead of a concert list made by fans request. And both this event propel AKB into public’s eye with RIVER as the proof that this kind of marketing is effective.

      In my opinion, the Janken tournament is much of a bane than a boon. Its difficult to promote a single without the popular members appearing in it and its release on December, a time of much spending for the Japanese public. But the management did it anyway to please the fans of unpopular members.

      Speaking of unpopular members, Aki-P did try to promote the members equally at the start but it didn’t work as the fans keep complaining that there are so many members they find it difficult to remember them so Aki-P choose a face for AKB and that is Acchan. And, this shift was marked by A2 Nagisa no Cherry. The management did try to promote the other girls still by having them in Side B each one having a chance at the front. If the fans like it they push her further if not they move on the next. The management push is only in response to fans reactions to the girls and there is no golden formula to this so its try and try.

      In terms of music, I do listen to Momoclo when I’m looking for variety but I’m keeping up with Aki-P’s songs, sakura song are still my thing and AKB, I believe, is unrivaled in this. Aki-P, after all, is Japan’s foremost songwriter having written the most. If he so wants with the influence he has gathered in his years in the industry I think he can contain Momoclo but industry wise they are helping keep the idol industry strong.

      As for the talent part, Aki-P didn’t enlist them for that what he sees is the potential in every girl. Its the school concept after all. AKB48 was just supposed to be a stopped over and not the finish line. If ever he push a girl like Acchan, Jurina or Meru, its because they have the perseverance to continue because he believes talent could be thought but character is inherent to the girl and they make a great center that could stand on top against criticism and hate.

      Enough AKB here’s my take on Momoclo.

      I think Momoclo was lucky to debut in 2010 after AKB stoke the idol fire in the public’s eye by having hits in 2009 and getting a million selling single in 2010. Momoclo’s concept is revolutionary in its industry its an eye opener to the different concept they can apply on idols. The music sure is catchy and the PV are creatively composed and the energy is sky high, more like a smorgasbord of Japans favorite past times. And they made it easy by color coding them like in Momosu.

      However, I don’t think Momoclo can keep the momentum, like AKB they will run out of cool idea in conceptualizing their famous random acts. Their members aren’t eternal either and similar to Acchan’s graduation they will rethink once again once Momota Kanako graduates.

      I have doubt about that #1 in the survey for idol ranking since I have no idea of its parameters and demographics. And also because of this. http://nihongogo.com/2013/08/the-idol-wars-which-group-will-unseat-akb48-as-king/

      AKB48 being the national idol group is the standard that every idol group is measured upon, a decade from now or so when historians write a history book about idols, I think what they will remember is the awards and records that AKB achieve. Oricon will continue to compare the future groups with AKB’s success. Momoclo being great on their own will live on the hearts of their fans but being a group without succession concept they will fade in time while AKB will live on maybe half of the popularity they once enjoy much like HP.

      PS. Too tired to make it coherent or content wise

    13. I only like akb48, but honestly i get really sad because some amazing and cute girls don’t get attention, and instead of focusing on the members that are on the group already all the management do is put new members, if wasn’t for miichan or some other girls (or the songs that i myself think are pretty good) i would’t care about AKB

    14. For me, you couldn’t have hit the nail any more squarely on the head than you did with this article. AKB48 never really grabbed my attention. Sure, I listen to their first album…occasionally. Maybe like once every month or three. Too many members, I’m not a fan of elections, graduations, etc. Too many girls, not enough interest in them.

      I truly enjoy the smaller idol units and the indie and underground idol scene more. Momoclo, Dempagumi.inc, Cheeky Parade, and many other even smaller groups. I love ゆるめるモ!, and バンドじゃないもん! a lot. The now defunct BiS is what really drew me into the idol music scene. I loved how unpredictable and volatile they were. That alt or anti-idol image made me take notice and actually want to listen and watch their videos/live recordings. I never had the opportunity to see them, but I have seen a number of their former members in their current idol/rock units. I thoroughly enjoy Billie Idle, Maison book girl, LUI FRONTiC 赤羽 JAPAN, POP, テンテンコ, BPM15Q, and Yufu Terashima.

      I’ve noticed that I tend to like many of the artists, (yes, I referred to them as artists) that are affiliated with the AVEX label and it’s subsidiaries. They actually market and have what I enjoy most in idol music entertainment.

      In regards to skill and talent. I have seen and taken notice of that. In addition to your mention on personality. That is one of the many factors I love about the smaller idol units. They don’t have to be technically perfect when dancing, nor do they have to never sing out of key. They have a likable amount of charm and appeal to them regardless. It is exactly this that makes me appreciate and support them even more.

      While AKB coined the “idols you can meet” and BiS introduced, “idols you can touch” to varying degrees of positive or negative response. It’s the fact that for me, the true charm and appeal lies with the more raw experience, personality, polish or roughness provided with the smaller groups/units.

    15. Momoiro Clover Z is the best!

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *